Friday, October 5, 2012

The Avengers

The avengers suffers from the same issue that any combined story does, too many main characters aka too many alpha characters. The truth is that it's not an impossible situation, it's just a difficult one to work with and most writers simply do not understand enough about true group dynamics to make it work.

Generally speaking too many equal powered alpha characters on one room causes no end of bickering and a severe lack of getting anything done. This dynamic can be really fun to write and work with for awhile as every character tries to one up and beat down every other character on set… but eventually you need to drive the group into a cohesive team. Unfortunately there are only a few choices how to get a group like this together quickly enough to make a movie work.

The setup for the movie, with every scene Fury entered in every other Marvel movie, gives the expectation of the true organization of SHIELD as governed by a truly powerful and intelligent mastermind. This would almost be a darkly manipulative Arthur character. The Arthur character here would represent the absolute King, prophesied, truly born, and too powerful, good and honestly badass to have anyone really question his authority. The Alpha's alpha as it were. This character would have the cards laid, the strategies already planned out and the team so well decided that everyone falls into their positions without understanding why.

The setup obviously not having the follow through it implied, another group option. So instead you have a series of equally powered men arguing in a room. Captained by the dynamic good guy (Captain America) and the "bad boy" (Stark). Now these two, truly being the most powerful characters, will fall into that endless head to head, like they do. The way around it? Powerful girl. Powerful girl doesn't necessarily have to play full alpha, but simply accepts no nonsense from the boys and speaks the reason that makes everyone listen to her. This is the horse herd dynamic, the boys can fight but the lead mare is who actually has to lead and take care of everyone while they do and when she's in trouble suddenly the boys can't fight each other anymore.

The third option is to create so fantastically huge and bad a bad guy that everyone has to work together in order to survive. This works sometimes and only if the specialization of their individual skills actually serves some purpose in teamwork or individual challenge situations.

The fourth is to create a leader out of one of the Marvel super villains who is able to fully go through the transformation into a good-guy character with those deep dark scars to impress everyone and truly lead because of that transformation and therefore the ability that none of the other characters have, the ability to see both sides.

Instead, they chose another route - kill the comic relief that none of the characters, only the viewers, actually cared about.

Sure, saving the Earth should be enough to unite them, but no, had to kill the comic relief first, that way the saving the Earth can make sense and they don't have to explain the appearance of the strange alien army that Loki can call up at whim. Honestly, why does anyone really need a backstory? Or names? As long as lots of things explode.

Or that could just make it boring. Skip the movie, watch the 15 minute climax fight, for two reasons - the animation of the giant flying whale turtle i cool and the lines "I have an army" "We have a Hulk". It's just not worth sitting through the hour and a half to see the writers vainly explain what leads up to the 15 minutes of the movie they wanted to make.

No comments:

Post a Comment